top of page

Are marketing agencies worth the money? What small businesses need to know

Hi, I’m Bry, founder of Hi This Is Bry. I’m a multi award winning Creative Strategist and Brand Consultant helping people build award worthy brands and make them visible. I write about branding, marketing, visibility and consumer behaviour, breaking down why recognisable brands succeed, why people buy and what you can apply to what you’re building.

Thinking of hiring a marketing agency? Before you spend thousands of pounds, there are a few things I think every business owner should know about what can happen behind the scenes. Having worked in agencies, in house and independently, I've experienced situations where the people responsible for delivering the work had little contact with the client, and concerns about whether a project was actually right for the business weren't always welcomed. That's not to say marketing agencies aren't worth the money, because I still work with and recommend some excellent ones. However, I wanted to share my experiences, explain why I eventually established my own consultancy and discuss what I'd recommend asking before investing in professional marketing support.


Pink laptop on a cream textured sofa displaying colourful pink and green sticky notes with marketing terms including SEO, content, ranking, backlinks and site architecture, illustrating the range of services offered by marketing agencies.

Are you getting expert advice or just being sold a service?

I've worked in marketing agencies, within businesses and independently, and one of the things I've found particularly frustrating throughout my career is how easily clients can end up paying for services that don't necessarily address the problems they're experiencing. I've worked with some excellent professionals and still recommend agencies to clients today, but I also think there are aspects of how some agencies operate that business owners should understand before committing substantial amounts of money to a project.

One of the biggest concerns I've encountered is the difference between the person responsible for selling a marketing service and the person who actually has the expertise to deliver it. When a business owner approaches an agency, they might have already decided that they need social media management or a new website, and the person handling their enquiry may be perfectly happy to discuss that service and arrange the booking. But what happens if the founder has misunderstood what's preventing their business from growing, and the service they've requested isn't actually the solution?

Having worked on projects where I've recognised problems with a client's wider business, I know how frustrating it can be when the work has already been agreed and there's little opportunity to question whether it's appropriate. In some cases, I've even been discouraged from raising concerns because the agency didn't want to jeopardise a project that had already been sold, and when you're an employee, suggesting something that could cost your employer money can be a rather uncomfortable position to find yourself in.

There were also occasions where, as the person actually designing or developing the marketing materials, I had very little direct contact with the client, because communication was being handled through a project manager. That created another difficulty, because even when I recognised something worth discussing, I couldn't necessarily raise it directly with the person paying for the work.

These experiences were among the reasons I eventually decided to establish my own consultancy, because I wanted to work directly with founders and have the freedom to explain what I genuinely believed their businesses needed.

Are marketing agencies actually worth paying for?

Yes, a good marketing agency can be an excellent investment, particularly when a business needs access to several different areas of expertise or doesn't have the resources to manage its marketing internally. Agencies can bring experienced professionals together and provide ongoing support that would be difficult for one person to deliver independently, especially when a business has several projects happening at once.

However, I think the value you receive depends on more than the quality of the work being produced, because somebody also needs to understand what your business is trying to achieve and whether the services being recommended are likely to help. A beautifully designed website might be exactly what one business needs, while another could have a perfectly good website and a much bigger problem with how its products are positioned.

In my experience, some of the most expensive mistakes happen when businesses invest in the wrong solution, particularly when they've approached a professional with an idea of what they need and nobody has properly examined whether that assumption is correct.

If you're spending thousands of pounds on marketing support, I think it's reasonable to expect somebody with relevant expertise to assess your situation before recommending what you should pay for, and I'd also want to understand how much access you'll have to the professionals responsible for the work.

Who actually decides what services an agency sells you?

When you approach a marketing agency, the first person you speak to might be a salesperson or project manager, although you could also find yourself dealing directly with the company director. There's nothing inherently wrong with that arrangement, particularly when an agency has a large team and needs somebody to coordinate enquiries, but I think it's worth understanding how much expertise that person has in the services they're recommending.

Imagine you're a small business owner who's struggling to attract customers, and you've decided that hiring somebody to manage your social media will help. You approach an agency and explain that you want someone to take over your accounts, create content and start bringing in more enquiries.

The person handling your enquiry discusses the package and explains what it includes, before arranging for the work to begin. Everything sounds perfectly reasonable, and you're happy because you've found somebody who can provide the service you were looking for.

But the specialist who will actually develop your content might not have been involved in that conversation, and they may only begin examining your business once the project has already been sold.

What happens if they discover that your social media has very little authority, your positioning is unclear or your website doesn't give potential customers enough reasons to trust you? The agency has already agreed to deliver a particular service, even though the specialist might reasonably believe that something else needs attention first.

This is where I think the sales process can create problems, because the person responsible for securing the booking may be concentrating on the service the client has requested, while the person responsible for delivering it could have recommended something completely different if they'd been involved earlier.

Will you actually speak to the person doing your marketing?

This is another question I'd encourage business owners to ask, because when I worked in agencies, it was entirely possible for the designers and marketers delivering a project to have very little direct contact with the client. Instead, communication would go through a project manager, who was responsible for gathering information and passing feedback between the business owner and the people completing the work.

Project managers can be incredibly valuable, particularly when they're coordinating several specialists and making sure projects are delivered properly. However, I found that this arrangement could create problems when somebody working on the project recognised something that needed a more detailed conversation with the client, especially when the concern involved the wider business rather than the specific design or marketing task they'd been assigned.

Imagine you're designing a website for somebody and, while reviewing their business, you realise their positioning is unclear or their services don't appear particularly competitive. You might want to ask the founder why they've chosen that particular approach, because understanding their reasoning could affect the recommendations you'd make and the decisions involved in designing the website.

But if you're communicating entirely through a project manager, you may have to explain those concerns internally and hope they're passed on, which introduces another opportunity for the conversation to be delayed or dismissed. The project manager may be concentrating on keeping the project moving according to the agreed brief, while you're trying to explain why something in that brief might need reconsidering.

I've experienced situations where this lack of direct contact made it harder to understand what the client actually needed, because there's a considerable difference between receiving a list of requested changes and having a conversation with the person who wants those changes made. Sometimes the most useful information comes from asking why somebody wants something, particularly when their original request is based on an assumption that might not be helping their business.

And when you combine limited client contact with internal concerns about questioning a project that's already been sold, it can become difficult for the person doing the work to communicate their professional judgement, even when they're the one who's spent the most time examining the problem.

I think founders should understand how communication will work before committing to an agency, particularly when they're paying for specialist expertise and expecting that expertise to influence the decisions being made. You may be perfectly happy having a project manager as your main contact, but I'd want to know that the people doing the work can raise important questions and that you'll have opportunities to discuss their recommendations when necessary.

What happens if the service you've booked isn't what your business needs?

This is something I've encountered personally, and I think it's particularly important for business owners to understand because you can invest substantial amounts of money into a professionally delivered project without necessarily addressing the underlying problem.

Imagine you've hired an agency to run advertising because your business isn't generating enough enquiries, but the specialist reviewing your website notices that your positioning is considerably weaker than that of your competitors. Perhaps you're charging similar prices to more established businesses, but you're providing very little information about your expertise or what makes your service worth choosing.

The advertising professional might be perfectly capable of producing a successful campaign, generating relevant traffic and bringing potential customers to your website. However, if those customers don't find convincing reasons to trust your business once they arrive, you could continue struggling to turn that attention into sales.

And this is where I think the wider business needs to be considered, because the advertising might be doing exactly what it's supposed to do while something else is preventing people from buying.

I've seen how problems with branding and positioning can affect the results businesses achieve through their marketing, which is why I believe the service being recommended should follow a proper assessment of what the business needs. If somebody has already committed to delivering a particular project before examining those things, they may find themselves trying to improve results without being able to address the issues affecting them.

The situation becomes even more frustrating when the specialist recognises that problem but isn't in a position to discuss it directly with the founder, because the client could be spending thousands of pounds without knowing that somebody involved in the work has serious reservations about whether the approach will deliver what they're hoping for.

See also: How to know if your brand is holding your business back

Why might an agency specialist be discouraged from giving honest advice?

This is probably the part of my experience that I've found most frustrating, because I've personally encountered situations where I've identified problems affecting a client's business but haven't been encouraged to communicate those concerns.

Sometimes the response has been along the lines of the client having already booked a particular project and the agency not wanting to lose it, while on other occasions, I've heard concerns that the client wouldn't be prepared to pay for proper strategy.

I found that incredibly frustrating, particularly when the client was already investing a substantial amount of money in professional services and the person with the expertise to identify a potential problem wasn't necessarily being given the opportunity to explain it.

But I also think it's important to understand the position that employees can find themselves in, because internal agency politics can make these conversations difficult. If you're working for somebody else and you recognise that a client has purchased something they might not actually need, raising that concern could mean questioning a decision that your manager or director has already made.

And when that project represents money coming into the business, suggesting that the client should reconsider their investment could potentially create problems for you internally. You might be worried about upsetting somebody more senior or being seen as difficult, particularly if you're working in an environment where challenging decisions isn't encouraged.

I've experienced enough of these situations to understand why somebody might decide that it's easier to complete the work they've been assigned rather than raise concerns that could cost their employer a project. That doesn't mean they agree with the decision, or that they lack the expertise to recognise the problem, but they may feel that speaking up could have consequences for their own working relationship.

I understand that agencies are businesses themselves, with employees to pay and revenue targets to meet, and I also recognise that a project may have a clearly defined scope that doesn't include a wider business assessment. However, if you've identified something that could seriously affect whether the work you're delivering achieves its intended purpose, I think the client deserves to know.

What I found difficult was being involved in projects where I suspected that the service being delivered wouldn't address the client's underlying problem, because it felt embarrassing to be providing professional work without being able to communicate what I'd actually identified.

And I think this is something agency owners should consider when developing their internal processes, because the people delivering the work often have valuable observations that could help clients make better decisions, particularly when they've spent time examining the business in detail. If those professionals don't feel comfortable questioning what's been sold, the agency could be overlooking information that would make the project more useful to the client.

Should marketing agencies tell clients when they've identified a bigger problem?

I think they should, particularly when the issue could affect whether the project they've been hired to deliver is successful, although I also believe there's an important distinction between identifying a problem and being expected to provide the entire solution for free.

Comprehensive strategy work involves research and professional judgement, and businesses should expect to pay for that expertise. If a client has hired somebody to design social media graphics, they can't reasonably expect a complete business strategy to be included simply because the designer has noticed weaknesses in their positioning.

However, recognising that a problem exists and communicating that concern is a different matter, because the professional could explain what they've observed and recommend further investigation without having to complete all the work involved in resolving it.

For example, if I noticed that a client's prices appeared inconsistent with how their business was positioned, I could explain that their presentation might be affecting how customers perceive the value of their services. That doesn't mean I need to produce a complete competitor analysis or develop an entirely new positioning strategy without being paid, but it does give the founder an opportunity to consider whether they want to investigate the issue further.

I think that's a reasonable expectation when you're paying for professional expertise, particularly when somebody has recognised an issue that could affect the outcome of the work they're delivering.

Ultimately, the business owner should be able to make an informed decision about what they want to invest in, and they can only do that when the people advising them are prepared to communicate what they've identified.

See also: What should you know before raising your business prices?

Can an agency be excellent at marketing but struggle with wider business strategy?

Absolutely, and I think this is another important consideration when choosing an agency, because marketing involves numerous specialisms and somebody can be exceptionally good at one area without having the experience needed to diagnose problems affecting the wider business. An agency might have a brilliant team of advertising professionals who understand how to reach the right audiences and improve campaign performance, but that doesn't automatically mean they're experienced in assessing a business's overall positioning or whether the product itself is commercially appealing.

If a campaign isn't generating the expected sales, the team might naturally examine the marketing they're responsible for, which could involve experimenting with different audiences or improving the advertising creative. Those changes may help, but if the underlying problem is that customers don't understand the value of the business, there may be limits to what those adjustments can achieve.

I think businesses sometimes assume that hiring a marketing agency means they're receiving advice on everything that could affect their ability to attract customers, when the agency may actually be concentrating on a much narrower area of responsibility.

That's why I'd encourage founders to understand what kind of assessment is being carried out before a service is recommended, particularly when they're approaching an agency because they're struggling to generate sales rather than simply needing help managing a specific marketing activity.

If the problem is broader than the marketing itself, the business may benefit from business strategy support that examines what customers are being offered and how they're likely to perceive it, before deciding which promotional activities deserve further investment.

See also: Why Isn't My Marketing Getting Results?

Why did I decide to start my own creative consultancy?

One of the biggest reasons I eventually decided to work independently was that I wanted the freedom to speak directly to business owners and give them a straight answer about what I believed their businesses actually needed, particularly when I'd identified problems that went beyond the service they'd originally been considering.

Having worked in agencies and in house, I'd experienced situations where commercial decisions and internal processes affected how much influence I had over the direction of a project. I found it frustrating when I could see opportunities to improve a client's positioning or recognised something that might affect their ability to attract customers, but wasn't necessarily in a position to raise those concerns.

And having limited contact with the clients themselves made that even more difficult, because I couldn't always have the conversations I wanted to have with the people whose businesses I was trying to help. I could spend considerable time examining their marketing and identifying potential improvements, but the recommendations I wanted to make might never reach them if they weren't considered relevant to the project that had already been agreed.

I wanted to work differently, which is why direct communication became such an important part of how I established Hi This Is Bry. When somebody approaches me about a particular service, I can examine what they're trying to achieve and explain if I believe something else deserves attention first, without needing approval from somebody whose priority might be protecting an existing booking.

If a founder thinks they need a new website but their existing website is perfectly capable of supporting their business with a few strategic improvements, I can tell them that rather than automatically recommending a complete rebuild. Equally, if somebody wants help attracting customers through social media but their branding isn't communicating the right level of expertise, I can explain why I'd want to consider that before developing a content strategy.

And if I believe something about the business isn't working, I'll explain what I've noticed and why I think it's worth addressing. I'm conscious that founders are often emotionally invested in their businesses, particularly when they've spent years building something themselves, but I also think people are paying me for my professional judgement and deserve to receive it.

This is something that has been reflected in feedback from my clients, including one who described a consultation as providing genuine professional opinion alongside reassurance and encouragement. I think that balance matters, because I want somebody to feel supported while still being able to have an honest conversation about what their business needs.

That freedom to assess the business and communicate my professional judgement is one of the things I value most about working independently, because it allows me to recommend the work I genuinely believe will benefit the founder, rather than feeling restricted by a project that's already been sold.

It's also why my creative services cover several areas of business development, because I don't believe every commercial problem can be solved by improving one particular marketing activity.

Do I still recommend marketing agencies to businesses?

Absolutely, and I think it's important to make that clear because I've worked with some excellent agency professionals and continue to recommend agencies when I believe they're the right choice for a project.

I'm still close to an agency I've worked with previously, and I refer clients to them when a project would benefit from a larger team or expertise that makes more sense to deliver through an agency.

One of the reasons I respect this particular business is that its founder is an experienced marketer herself, which means she understands the services she's selling and has the professional knowledge to assess what a client is likely to need.

She also makes an effort to educate her clients, helping them understand the thinking behind her recommendations rather than simply expecting them to purchase a service without understanding why it might benefit their business.

And I think that makes a considerable difference, because when the person leading an agency understands the actual work being delivered, they're better equipped to question a client's assumptions and recognise when a different approach may be more appropriate.

That doesn't mean every agency director needs to personally deliver every service, because larger agencies naturally rely on specialists with different skills, but I do think the people responsible for recommending and approving projects should understand enough to make informed decisions or involve the relevant experts before the work is sold.

I also think good agency leadership should create an environment where those specialists feel comfortable raising concerns, even when doing so might lead to an awkward conversation with a client or require reconsidering a project that's already been agreed. If the people delivering the work have valuable expertise, it makes sense to allow that expertise to influence the direction of the project.

For me, that particular agency is an example of how responsible leadership can influence the experience clients receive, and it's one of the reasons I'm happy to continue recommending their services.

When is hiring a marketing agency a good investment?

I think agencies can provide excellent value when a business genuinely needs the combination of expertise and practical support they offer, particularly when a project involves several different specialists or requires ongoing work that would be difficult for one person to manage independently.

A growing business might need a team to coordinate its advertising and manage content production while also maintaining its website, and an established agency may be well placed to provide that support. Having professionals who can collaborate on different parts of the work can be extremely valuable, particularly when the agency has processes that allow them to communicate effectively and understand how their responsibilities relate to the client's wider objectives.

However, I'd still want to know how the agency determines which services a business needs, because having a large team doesn't automatically guarantee that the original recommendation was appropriate.

I'd also want to understand how closely those specialists work with the client, particularly when the project involves strategic decisions that could benefit from direct conversations rather than relying entirely on information passed between several people.

If you've already established a clear direction for your marketing and need professionals to help deliver the work, an agency could be an excellent choice. If you're still trying to understand why your business isn't attracting customers, I'd be more interested in whether the agency has somebody capable of diagnosing that problem before recommending a substantial package.

And if you're running a smaller business with a limited budget, I'd also consider whether you actually need ongoing agency support yet, because an occasional consultation or focused strategic project might help you make better decisions without immediately committing to a monthly retainer.

See also: Should I hire a social media manager or a social media strategist?

What should you ask a marketing agency before hiring them?

One of the first things I'd want to understand is who will actually assess your business before a service is recommended, particularly if you're approaching the agency because you're struggling to achieve a particular commercial result.

If you're speaking to a salesperson or project manager, there's nothing wrong with asking whether the specialist responsible for delivering the work will be involved in the initial discussions. You might also want to understand how the agency evaluates whether the service you've requested is appropriate, especially if you've already tried similar approaches without achieving the results you expected.

I'd also ask how much direct contact you'll have with the designers or marketers responsible for your project, because there's a difference between having a project manager coordinate the work and having no opportunity to speak to the person making the creative or strategic decisions. If you want to understand why somebody has recommended a particular approach, I'd want to know whether you'll be able to discuss that with them.

Another important question is what happens when the specialists identify concerns that weren't covered in the original brief, particularly when those concerns could affect whether the project achieves its intended purpose. Does the agency encourage its staff to raise those issues, and will somebody explain them to you before continuing with work that might need reconsidering?

For example, if you've hired an agency to manage advertising and the team discovers that your website is preventing potential customers from enquiring, would somebody explain that to you? Would they recommend further work or simply continue delivering the advertising package you'd originally purchased?

Neither question requires the agency to provide an entire strategy for free, but the answers could tell you quite a lot about how they approach their responsibilities to clients.

I'd also want to understand what results the agency is actually responsible for delivering, because generating website traffic and increasing sales are different objectives. If you're paying for a particular service, you should know how its performance will be evaluated and what other factors might influence the commercial results you're hoping to achieve.

Finally, I'd pay attention to whether the agency seems interested in understanding your business before discussing what it can sell you. If somebody is recommending a substantial package without asking meaningful questions about your existing marketing or the problems you're experiencing, I'd want to understand how they've reached that recommendation.

Should you hire an agency or an independent consultant?

I think this depends on what your business actually needs, because agencies and independent consultants can offer different advantages, and the size of the provider doesn't automatically determine the quality of the advice you'll receive.

An agency may be better suited to a project requiring a larger team or several specialist services being delivered at the same time, particularly when the business needs ongoing practical support. An independent consultant can be useful when you want to work directly with somebody who will assess your situation and develop recommendations around your specific commercial challenges.

Of course, these aren't fixed rules, because some independent consultants also deliver substantial projects and some agencies provide excellent strategic advice directly through their specialists. For me, the important thing is understanding who you're actually working with and whether they have the expertise to address the problem you're trying to solve.

I work directly with founders because I want to understand how their businesses operate and how customers are likely to perceive what they're offering, which allows me to make recommendations based on the wider business rather than concentrating exclusively on one area of marketing.

It also means that when I recognise something that could be affecting the success of a project, I can discuss it directly with the person responsible for the business, rather than relying on internal processes to determine whether that conversation happens. I think that makes a difference to the kind of relationship I can develop with clients, because they know they're speaking to the person actually examining their business and carrying out the work.

If you're unsure what kind of support you need, my brand and business consultation provides an opportunity to discuss the problems you're experiencing and consider which areas might deserve attention before committing to a larger project.

See also: What happens in a £60 brand, website and social media consultation?

What else should you know before hiring a marketing agency?

Are marketing agencies worth the money for small businesses? A good marketing agency can provide excellent value when a small business needs the expertise and practical support being offered, particularly if it doesn't have an internal marketing team. However, I'd recommend understanding what the agency will actually deliver and whether those services address the problems your business is experiencing before committing to a substantial fee.

Will I speak directly to the people working on my project? That depends on how the agency operates, because some provide direct access to designers and marketers while others coordinate communication through a project manager. I'd recommend asking how specialist feedback is shared and whether you'll be able to discuss important creative or strategic decisions with the people responsible for them.

Should a marketing agency tell me if my branding needs improving? If an agency identifies a significant issue with your branding that could affect the success of the work you're paying for, I believe it should explain that concern. You shouldn't expect a complete brand strategy to be included for free, but being made aware of a potential problem allows you to decide whether further professional support would be worthwhile.

Is an independent marketing consultant better than an agency? That depends on the type of support you need and the experience of the people involved. An independent consultant may offer more direct access to the person assessing your business, while an agency can provide a broader team of specialists, so I'd focus on their expertise and approach rather than assuming one type of provider is always better.

What should I do if I've already paid an agency but my marketing isn't working? Start by reviewing what the agency agreed to deliver and whether those responsibilities are being fulfilled, because disappointing sales don't automatically mean the marketing itself has been ineffective. If the campaigns are generating relevant attention but customers aren't enquiring, it's worth discussing whether other problems with the business could be affecting the results before investing in further promotion.

How can you tell whether a marketing agency is right for your business?

I think the most important thing to consider before hiring a marketing agency is whether the people advising you genuinely understand what your business needs, particularly when you're preparing to invest substantial amounts of money in professional support.

Having worked across different types of marketing environments, I've seen how valuable agencies can be when their teams are experienced and their leadership encourages honest communication. I've also experienced situations where the way projects were sold and managed made it difficult to question whether the work would actually address the client's underlying problem, particularly when the people delivering the work had very little direct contact with the client.

Those experiences ultimately influenced my decision to establish my own consultancy, because I wanted to work directly with business owners and feel comfortable giving them my professional opinion, even when that meant suggesting they reconsider something they were originally planning to pay for.

For me, the quality of an agency's advice matters just as much as the quality of the work it produces, because founders should have access to informed recommendations and the opportunity to understand why a particular service is being proposed.

If you're about to spend thousands of pounds on marketing, I'd want to know that somebody has properly examined what your business needs before deciding what you should buy, and that the professionals involved would feel comfortable telling you if they'd identified a better approach.

Want to understand what your business might actually need?

Before committing to an agency package, my free Business Visibility Playbook can help you review how potential customers discover and evaluate your business, including where gaps in your presentation or messaging could be affecting their confidence. It's a useful place to start if you're considering investing in marketing support but want to understand which problems might need addressing first.

1.png

BEFORE YOU GO...

Not sure what to focus on next?

If this article has given you ideas but you are not sure what needs your attention first, my free Visibility Playbook can help.
 

Use it to privately review how your business is showing up across branding, your website, content and wider visibility, spot the gaps that matter most, then turn what you find into a practical plan for what to focus on next.
 

No need to become a marketing expert. Just get a clearer picture of what is working, what needs attention and where your time is most likely to make a difference.

Get to know me!

Hi, I’m Bry, an Essex and Suffolk based Creative Strategist and neurodivergent founder.
 

I help people build award worthy brands and make them visible, from shaping their positioning and visual identity to creating custom Wix websites and social media strategies that attract buyers. I also help them build authority through awards, features and content that gets their work noticed.
 

My work has been recognised across branding, websites, content creation and business development, including UK Top 10 Best Business Branding, UK Top 100 Best Creative Arts Business, silver for Young Entrepreneur of the Year at the SME Awards, Web Branding Agency of the Year at the South England Prestige Awards 2026/27, plus shortlists at the East of England StartUp Awards and Enterprise Vision Awards.

HTIB 2026 Headshot.png
HTIB Hand Icon

©Hi This Is Bry

UK-based, working remotely with small businesses across the UK and internationally.

Mailing address: 61 Bridge Street, Kington HR5 3DJ

bottom of page