Should I hire a social media manager or a social media strategist?
Hi, I’m Bry, founder of Hi This Is Bry. I’m a multi award winning Creative Strategist and Brand Consultant helping people build award worthy brands and make them visible. I write about branding, marketing, visibility and consumer behaviour, breaking down why recognisable brands succeed, why people buy and what you can apply to what you’re building.
I've noticed that whenever the subject of hiring a social media manager comes up, there's often a discussion about what a manager does and doesn't provide. Some are quick to explain that they don't design graphics or develop strategies, which raises a fairly reasonable question from a business owner's perspective: what exactly am I paying you to do?
If you're considering hiring a social media manager or a social media strategist, understanding that difference could save you a considerable amount of money, especially if you're running a small business with a limited marketing budget.
I'm a creative strategist who works directly with founders, and in my experience, many solopreneurs and businesses with fewer than ten employees would benefit more from improving their social media strategy before paying somebody to manage their accounts. That doesn't mean managers aren't useful. It means you need to be clear about the problem you're hiring somebody to solve, because maintaining an account that's struggling to generate enquiries won't necessarily improve its results.

What's the difference between a social media manager and a strategist?
If your social media is already attracting the right people and generating interest, but you're struggling to keep up with publishing and customer interactions, hiring a social media manager could be a very sensible next step. If you're posting regularly and wondering why it isn't leading to enquiries or sales, I'd look at strategy first. A social media strategist examines who you're reaching, what your content is communicating and how to give potential customers better reasons to trust you and buy.
In my opinion, that's often the more pressing problem for a growing small business. My approach centres on developing authority and sales through thought leadership, which means helping founders use their experience and opinions to become people their audience recognises and trusts.
What does a social media manager actually do?
This is where hiring can become a bit of a lottery, because the job title tells you surprisingly little about what's included. One manager might create graphics, write captions and develop a content plan, while another provides scheduling, account administration and replies to comments. Others may coordinate photographers or editors, produce reports or manage paid campaigns. There are capable people offering all sorts of combinations, but you need to look at the actual service rather than assuming the title comes with a fixed list of responsibilities.
It's also worth being realistic about cost, someone who can develop a sales focused strategy, create strong graphics, edit video, manage an audience and handle the everyday running of several platforms is a fairly rare find. If they can do all of that well, they're unlikely to charge the same as somebody providing basic scheduling. Expecting one affordable freelancer to act as an entire marketing department is asking quite a lot of one human being.
Results can be even harder to pin down, you might expect your social media manager to grow your following or increase sales, while their agreement only covers keeping your account active. Management, growth and sales are different responsibilities, even if some providers combine them. Before signing up to a monthly fee, ask who decides what gets posted, who creates the content and how you'll measure whether the service is working. If the person you're hiring offers strategy too, fantastic, but make sure that's genuinely part of the package you're buying.
Does a small business need a social media manager?
Social media managers can be incredibly helpful for large companies and medium sized organisations with lots happening across their accounts, even startups with small teams may benefit from having someone take responsibility for publishing and customer messages. When you're receiving significant engagement or running several campaigns at once, managing social media can become a job in itself, and delegating that work is a perfectly sensible business decision.
But if you're a solopreneur or one of a handful of people running a business, I think it's worth asking whether management is your biggest problem right now. If you publish a few times a week, receive a manageable number of comments and still aren't consistently bringing in customers, what will hiring somebody to keep those posts going actually change? You may end up paying a monthly fee for somebody to maintain an approach that wasn't working particularly well in the first place. In my experience, many smaller businesses could do far more with a better understanding of what content helps them sell before they spend money getting somebody else to publish it.
How can small businesses build trust on social media?
A business with a well known name and a large team already has certain advantages when somebody discovers it for the first time. A solopreneur doesn't necessarily have that same instant credibility. People may assume a smaller operation has less experience or fewer resources, even when the person behind it knows their subject inside out. That means smaller businesses often have to work harder to show potential customers why they're capable of doing the job.
But there's an advantage here too, when someone chooses to work with an independent founder, they may be choosing that person specifically. They want to understand how you think, hear your opinions and know who they'll actually be dealing with. You can demonstrate deeper expertise and be more approachable than a company where every interaction goes through a different department. I think your social media should make the most of that, because your knowledge and your personality can give someone a very good reason to choose you.
This is where thought leadership becomes particularly valuable, by thought leadership, I mean using your own professional experience and judgement to contribute useful ideas to conversations in your industry. You might explain why you disagree with a common piece of advice, talk through a decision you made for a client or point out a problem your customers may not have recognised yet.
That gives people a much better idea of how you'd approach their own situation than another generic post announcing that you offer a service. Over time, that recognition can help build the authority and trust people need before they decide to spend money with you.
How many followers do you need to make sales on social media?
A lot of social media advice still concentrates on audience growth, and I understand why. More people seeing your content can create opportunities, but follower numbers aren't the same as sales. I've worked with founders who had well under 10,000 followers and were still able to generate business through their content. They didn't need a huge audience of people who enjoyed watching them, they just needed potential customers to understand what they offered and why working with them made sense.
That's what I concentrate on when developing content with founders, I want somebody landing on your profile to find useful reasons to trust you, alongside enough personality to get a sense of who you are. If a potential customer has been wondering whether they need your service, your content can address that hesitation before they ever send an enquiry. Someone with a smaller following who communicates those things well may be in a much better position to make sales than someone with thousands of followers who have little interest in buying.
See also: Why isn't my social media getting me clients? Here's the honest answer from a Creative Strategist
How can thought leadership help you attract clients on LinkedIn?
When I worked with Kate Edwards HR Solutions, the aim was to help an experienced workplace mediation professional become more recognisable for the knowledge she already had. We used LinkedIn because the HR professionals and managers she wanted to reach were there. I researched the conversations happening in her industry, interviewed Kate about her experiences and helped turn her thinking into posts that people could learn from. Instead of relying on generic HR advice, we drew on the situations she had encountered and the opinions she had developed through her work.
In the first month, her LinkedIn content generated 9,721 impressions and her follower count increased by 7.6%. More importantly for our approach, her personal stories were among the strongest performing posts and other HR professionals began resharing her ideas. Those results helped us understand what her professional audience actually wanted to hear, so we could adjust the content rather than carry on publishing the same things regardless of the response. The figures demonstrate reach and engagement, rather than proving a specific number of sales.
At that stage I also handled the practical side of content creation and scheduling for Kate, so I know first hand how much work good management involves. My current approach places more emphasis on helping founders understand the strategy themselves, particularly how to use thought leadership to establish authority and create opportunities for enquiries and sales. That experience is a big part of why I believe the thinking behind the content deserves as much attention as the process of publishing it.
See also: Kate Edwards HR Solutions: LinkedIn strategy for a workplace mediation brand
What is a signature series and how does it help?
One of the things I help founders develop is a signature content series, which is a recognisable format they can return to regularly. Rather than waking up every week wondering what on earth to post, they have a way of communicating their expertise that fits what their potential customers need to know. For example, an HR consultant could regularly explain situations employers run into at work and what they should consider doing about them. The format stays familiar, while each instalment answers a different question a potential client might have.
A good series can help people become familiar with the founder, demonstrate the depth of their thinking and answer questions that influence buying decisions. It also makes creating content far more manageable, because the founder doesn't have to invent a completely new idea or style every time. That's one of the reasons I think strategic support can be such a useful investment early on.
You're building an approach you understand and can carry on using yourself, rather than becoming dependent on somebody else to tell you what to post next. When that series is built around the founder's opinions and real experience, it can develop their thought leadership while giving potential customers a repeated opportunity to see their expertise in action.
See also: What should I post on social media for my business? A guide to getting more engagement
Do I need a social media manager to post my Reels?
We also need to talk about video, reels are a serious part of getting discovered on social media, and talking directly to the camera gives people an opportunity to hear your expertise and get a feel for your personality. I think that's particularly useful for founders whose knowledge is a big part of what they're selling. You can't expect a social media manager to turn up on camera as you and speak from your experience. If you're the person customers are considering hiring, there's a strong argument for you being the person they hear from.
And here's the practical question. If you've thought of the idea, recorded the Reel and edited the video yourself, how much work is left to outsource? Of course a manager might handle editing, captions or scheduling as part of their package, and those services can save time. But if you're already doing most of the creative work and only publishing a few times a week, uploading the finished Reel yourself may be a perfectly manageable task. Before paying someone every month to do it for you, I'd want to know what you could achieve by putting that budget into improving the content itself.
Should I respond to my own social media comments and DMs?
The same applies to comments and direct messages, if your business receives a huge number of enquiries every day, having somebody manage those interactions can be invaluable. I can completely understand a founder wanting help when their inbox is filling up faster than they can respond. But if you're getting a few comments on your posts and the occasional message asking about your services, why wouldn't you reply as yourself while you build your business?
Those interactions give people direct access to the person they may eventually buy from, they also tell you what your audience is confused about, what they're interested in and which questions keep coming up before somebody makes a purchase. That's useful information for your future content. If personal service is one of the reasons people choose a smaller business, I'd be reluctant to outsource that opportunity before the volume of messages actually makes it necessary.
Can AI generated content damage customer trust?
I also think businesses need to consider where social media is heading as generative AI becomes more common, by generative AI, I mean tools that create images or videos based on a prompt. Businesses can now produce convincing looking content without photographing a product or recording a real person, but that creates obvious problems when the result misrepresents what customers will actually receive. It can also make people more suspicious of the content they're seeing.
Platforms are already giving audiences more control. For example, Pinterest introduced settings that let users see fewer AI generated images in certain categories, including food and drink, while TikTok announced tests of a tool to adjust how much AI generated content appears in the For You feed. That doesn't mean people can universally filter out every piece of AI content, but it's a pretty clear indication that platforms recognise some users want more control over it.
Meta has also expanded AI labelling across advertisements, including the detection of content created with other companies' AI tools. In the US, advertisers are already required to disclose certain uses of AI in political and social issue adverts, so there's increasing attention on how synthetic content is presented to customers.
Then there's the recent Just Eat AI food photography controversy, In October 2026, Just Eat faced criticism after AI generated menu images inaccurately represented dishes, including one memorable example where a breakfast soda was interpreted as food floating in a fizzy drink. The company apologised and suspended its trial. Imagine being a small restaurant whose food is represented by a picture that looks nothing like the meal someone is going to receive. Even without a formal advertising ruling, the backlash can be a problem for customer trust.
UK advertising guidance already says product imagery must not give customers a misleading impression, regardless of whether the picture was made with AI or conventional photography. My personal prediction is that we'll see tighter and more specific restrictions on generative AI in advertising, particularly where images or videos could mislead people about what they're buying. Recent high profile cases have only strengthened that view.
I wouldn't build a small business's content strategy around the assumption that synthetic images and videos will always be received positively, especially when the founder has genuine expertise and a real voice they could be sharing instead.
See also: AI logo risks every business should know
What happens if my social media manager goes on holiday?
There's another reason I'm keen for founders to understand their own strategy. What happens when the person managing your account isn't available? They might go on holiday, get ill, stop freelancing or decide they no longer want to work with your business. They're entitled to do all of those things, and when you're working with a freelance manager in particular, you can't assume they'll always be around to make decisions for you.
But if they've always decided what to post and how to communicate your services, do you know what to do when they're gone? Do you know which content has been bringing in enquiries, why certain ideas have worked and what you should do if those enquiries slow down? I think a founder should be able to answer those questions about their own business, even when somebody else is responsible for the practical running of the accounts. Otherwise, you could find yourself unable to continue your marketing because one person is away for a fortnight.
This is a major reason I work directly with founders and concentrate on helping them understand sales and growth strategy through thought leadership. I want them to know why they're making particular content decisions and how those decisions relate to customers. Most people who use social media regularly already know how to upload a Reel.
They need to understand what to say in it, why it matters to their audience and how it might encourage someone to enquire. When they eventually hire somebody to manage the work, they can brief that person properly and still understand what's happening in their own business.
When should I hire a social media manager?
For me, the strongest time to consider hiring a manager is when you know what you're trying to achieve, have a content approach that's moving in the right direction and find that the practical workload is becoming difficult to keep up with. Maybe your inbox is constantly busy or you're publishing across several channels while managing a growing business. At that point, having someone take care of the everyday running of your social media can free you up to concentrate on work that needs your attention.
Of course, you might find a brilliant social media manager who also develops strategy and understands how to improve sales. Those people exist, and if their package covers what your business needs, great. Just recognise that you're buying a broader level of expertise and should expect the price to reflect it. My concern is with smaller businesses paying for account management because they assume that keeping an account active will automatically make it grow or start generating sales.
If you're unsure where to spend your budget, look at what has actually happened on your account recently. Have particular posts led to questions about your services? Are people watching your videos but still unsure what you offer? Are you genuinely struggling to keep up with conversations, or are you struggling to start them?
Those answers will tell you far more than simply deciding you need someone to take social media off your hands. If you're struggling to work out what needs attention first, my Visibility Consultation gives us an hour to examine what's happening and decide where your effort could make the biggest difference.
See also: What happens in a £60 brand, website and social media consultation?
Should I invest in social media strategy before hiring a manager?
In my experience, for a lot of solopreneurs and very small teams, yes. I'd rather see a founder understand how to communicate their expertise and produce content that supports sales before spending money every month to keep an account ticking over.
That's the thinking behind my social media strategy and marketing support, where I work directly with business owners to build authority and sales through thought leadership. That includes helping them develop their own opinions into useful content, understand the decisions that encourage people to buy and create signature series they can keep using themselves.
If you've already been posting for a while and want a professional review of what's working, I offer a £180 review of your current content, account analytics and opportunities to improve. You can explore my Strategic Social Media Refresh package here, including further details about what's involved and how to enquire.
See also: What's included in a £180 Strategic Social Media Refresh for small businesses?
For founders who want a more complete plan, my Social Media Strategy and Support package includes audience research, content direction, custom signature series and three months of support to review and adjust the approach. The goal is to help you understand what content can build your authority and encourage enquiries, so you can make better decisions about your own marketing without needing somebody else to run the account for you.
See also: What's included in a £450 Social Media Strategy and Support package for small businesses?
Once you know what works and the workload becomes too much, hire a manager to help keep it running. If you've reached that stage already, there may be every reason to hire one now. But if the real problem is that your social media isn't helping people understand why they should buy from you, I'd put the strategy first. Paying somebody else to spin the wheels won't automatically get you anywhere.
What should I know before hiring social media support?
Can a social media manager also be a strategist? Yes. Some managers provide strategic planning alongside account management, content creation and reporting. The important thing is checking exactly which responsibilities are included in the package and whether its price reflects the work involved.
Do small businesses need a social media manager? Some do, particularly when the founder lacks time or the account receives more messages and content requests than the team can manage. In my experience, many solopreneurs and very small businesses would benefit from improving their approach to generating enquiries before committing to ongoing management fees.
Do you need thousands of followers to make sales on social media? No. A smaller audience can still contain people who genuinely want what you sell. The content needs to help those people understand your expertise and feel confident enough to enquire or purchase.
Should I post my own Reels or hire someone to do it? If you're already planning, recording and editing your videos, publishing them yourself may be manageable while your account is small. A manager becomes more useful when coordinating content and handling engagement takes significant time away from the rest of your business.
What happens if my social media manager leaves? Ideally, you'll still understand your audience, know what content has been working and have access to your accounts and content files. A good handover helps, but learning the thinking behind your social media strategy makes it easier to continue independently or brief a replacement.
How can I tell if my social media is helping me get customers?
If your social media regularly attracts questions about your services and helps potential customers understand why they should work with you, that's a useful sign that your content is supporting the business. Look at whether people are visiting your website or mentioning particular posts when they enquire. If you're getting attention but very little interest in what you sell, it may be worth reviewing the content itself before spending more money on account management.
My free Business Visibility Playbook can help you look at how potential customers discover your business and what might be making them hesitate before getting in touch.

BEFORE YOU GO...
Not sure what to focus on next?
If this article has given you ideas but you are not sure what needs your attention first, my free Visibility Playbook can help.
Use it to privately review how your business is showing up across branding, your website, content and wider visibility, spot the gaps that matter most, then turn what you find into a practical plan for what to focus on next.
No need to become a marketing expert. Just get a clearer picture of what is working, what needs attention and where your time is most likely to make a difference.
Get to know me!
Hi, I’m Bry, an Essex and Suffolk based Creative Strategist and neurodivergent founder.
I help people build award worthy brands and make them visible, from shaping their positioning and visual identity to creating custom Wix websites and social media strategies that attract buyers. I also help them build authority through awards, features and content that gets their work noticed.
My work has been recognised across branding, websites, content creation and business development, including UK Top 10 Best Business Branding, UK Top 100 Best Creative Arts Business, silver for Young Entrepreneur of the Year at the SME Awards, Web Branding Agency of the Year at the South England Prestige Awards 2026/27, plus shortlists at the East of England StartUp Awards and Enterprise Vision Awards.

